If the headline above has given you déjà vu, that’s because we’ve shared this piece with you before, back in July of 2024. The reason we’re resending it today is that, in the years since, it has been turned into a documentary on Paramount+—called “He Said, She Said: Till Death Do Us Part”—which will be available to stream starting Tuesday, November 17. I’ve seen the first episode—and it’s haunting.
If I had to describe this story in three words, it’d be “world’s worst divorce.” Allan Kassenoff and Catherine Youssef were high-flying New York City litigators, living in a dark-wood-paneled house in Westchester with their three daughters—until their relationship unraveled into screaming matches, abuse allegations, and a bitter custody battle that remains infamous in the county’s family court.
The divorce was still ongoing when, in the spring of 2023, Allan received a horrifying email: Catherine had traveled to Switzerland, where she would die by assisted suicide.
And that’s when the campaign to destroy his life began in earnest.
When Frannie started digging into the story of the Kassenoffs, she found that nothing was as it seemed. To get to the truth, she spent more than eight months speaking to dozens of people and reading hundreds of documents—and soon realized that this isn’t only the story of one family’s domestic dispute. It’s a story about how social media can distort our perceptions, and courtrooms can flatten our judgement, both of them boiling even the most complicated human beings down into stock characters in simple tales of good and evil.
“More than any story I’ve ever worked on, this one kept me up at night,” Frannie told the audience last week at a screening of the first episode of the docuseries. I think you’ll see why. —Freya Sanders
This is a story that ends with my own assisted death in Switzerland.
That is how the suicide note began.
Allan Kassenoff was standing in the driveway of his Westchester home on Saturday, May 27, 2023, when he read it. His wife, Catherine, had emailed it to dozens of people—including judges, attorneys, journalists, police, friends, and even staff at Allan’s law firm, Greenberg Traurig—but she hadn’t sent it to her husband. A colleague had forwarded it to him.
Allan and Catherine had spent the previous four years fighting in court over the custody of their three young daughters. After millions of dollars, and over 3,000 court filings, the divorce still hadn’t been finalized.
In four single-spaced pages, the email detailed how Allan had been an abusive husband who had manipulated the corrupt court system into cutting off Catherine’s parental rights. She accused him of “ruining the lives of my children, me,” and so many other “parents (mostly mothers) who have tried to stand up against abuse.”
“Perhaps if I had not been re-diagnosed with cancer I could have lasted in this fight longer,” she wrote, disclosing a recurrence not even her closest friends had known about, and which Allan told me he doesn’t believe was real. “But I do not have the strength to go forward,” she concluded.
Catherine also embedded a Dropbox link that included hundreds of court documents, police reports, her children’s therapy records, and videos of her husband yelling—evidence that showed, she wrote, “exactly how abusive Allan Kassenoff is.”
While reading Catherine’s suicide note, Allan started to cry, he told me. “I felt bad for her,” he said. But he also admits he felt relieved. According to him, his wife was the abusive one, and had “made my life a living hell for so long.”
But while Catherine’s story may have ended that day, Allan’s torment had only just begun. In her suicide note, Catherine told readers, “Don’t let my death be in vain.” And whether she knew it or not, there were plenty of people willing to avenge her.
To keep reading this terrifying story—which is all about pride, vengeance, and the disturbing truth about what goes viral—click below:
