Intro: Hello, and thanks to Ted for handing over the keys. I write television. I’m on NBC’s Line of Fire right now, and before that Gossip Girl, Quantico and God Friended Me. I also write a newsletter called Breaking Story, which is mostly a record of things I learned the slow way.
This is about a pitch of mine that died in a room full of writers, and about why two people who had no time for me spent some of it anyway to give me a second chance. I have been on both sides of that since, and I didn’t always choose well.
Proof
Years ago I was the writers’ assistant on a television show called Proof, about a surgeon investigating cases that explore the possibility of an afterlife. The assistant job is what it sounds like. You sit in the room where the writers break the stories, which means arguing an episode into existence beat by beat before anyone writes a word of it, and you take down everything that gets said and organize it carefully.
I want to be precise about my standing in that room, because it turns out to be the whole point.
I was the favorite. My notes were coming out close to outlines, tidy enough that the writers could take them away and polish instead of rebuild. My pitches were landing. And… this is the part people don’t talk about, and it’s the most important… I was easy to work with. People liked me.
So the showrunner offered me a freelance episode, which in television is the audition. You’re not on the staff, and for one episode you get treated as though you might be.
I wrote a one-pager. A grieving mother becomes convinced her dead son has been reincarnated in the body of a boy who survived a near-death experience, and across the hour the boy takes on more and more of her son’s qualities.
I brought it in and everyone read it.
And then I sat through twenty minutes of deafening silence.
The showrunner and his second in command stood up and walked out. I sat there in a room full of writers and not one of them said good job. Everybody in there had understood something about me before I did, and I sat inside that sickening feeling. I felt like I was waiting to be called into the principal’s office. Eventually the vice principal called me in.
He sat me down and said I was a talented writer and the story wasn’t there yet, and that it happens. Then he told me why. It was too linear. There were escalations but no turns and no surprises, just a slow unfolding and the same clue arriving in slightly different clothes. My episode started in one place and ended in the same place.
He was dead right, pardon the pun.
My stomach dropped. He told me to keep at it and maybe I’d crack it later, then gave me five minutes to put myself back together because he could tell I was teetering on tears. Then I went back in and took notes and felt impossibly small for the rest of that week.
And then… I rewrote the story. I turned the thing on its head. Same mother, same reincarnated son, except now the son had been a prodigy at the piano and the boy who survived starts playing like him without ever having had a lesson. We learn she’s made the claim before, about other boys, more than once. She’s obsessed and broken and grieving. And right at the point where she looks completely, sadly wrong, she makes a rare diagnosis about the boy that saves his life, because he has the same condition her son had and she didn’t catch it in time.
I got the freelance. It shot ahead of another script the network had thrown out, which bought the show time to rebuild that one while mine was in front of cameras. I felt like the favorite again.
I was the favorite at my lowest. That’s why I got the tough love in the first place.
Two things I was given
For years I told that as a story about a good note.
I got the note. I also got the second attempt, and those are not the same gift. Somebody decided the failed pitch was a bad morning rather than a permanent verdict on my talent, and that decision got made in a hallway I wasn’t standing in, by two people on a struggling show who did not have the time they spent on me.
They spent it because they’d already chosen me.
I don’t think they’d have put it that way. Nobody in that hallway was doing arithmetic about who deserved grace or tough love or a second chance. But I’d been in that room for months being liked, and the liking is what made the twenty minutes possible.
What a note actually costs
Telling somebody their work doesn’t work is not a question of courage, and it costs two separate things.
The first is labor. To give a real note you have to diagnose what’s broken, which means reading closely enough to find the actual fault instead of the symptom, and then, if you’re being generous, figuring out what might fix it. That’s hours, and they aren’t on anyone’s schedule.
The second is worse, and it’s the one people lie about, often to themselves.
We say we don’t want to give the hard note because it will hurt someone’s feelings. I don’t think that’s it. I think we don’t want to feel the discomfort of having hurt them. The flinch, the silence, the way somebody’s face goes when you tell them the thing they made isn’t good enough. Protecting them from the truth is not an act of kindness. It’s selfish.
And both of those costs get paid out of the same account, which is whatever strength you have that day. There’s the show, always behind. There’s whatever else is happening in your life. And there’s the person in front of you, who is either someone you have a bond with or someone you don’t.
The bond is everything. It’s what gets you past the exhaustion and the schedule and into the slow, unpleasant work of telling someone the truth that to take a step forward, they must take a step back and you need to take it with them.
Which is why the same person behaves two completely different ways in one week. A friend of a friend sends you a script and it’s terrible, and you tell them it’s great and give two perfunctory notes and move on, because the real answer would cost you a day and an uncomfortable phone call. Then somebody you love sends you a flat pilot and you clear an afternoon and get in there and tell them exactly what’s broken and talk through how to make it better.
The difference is the relationship.
The version of this at the top
It happens in TV and film alike. You see it in pitches all the time now.
The executive takes the meeting from behind a laptop. You pitch. They say it’s “well told” (which, if you’ve taken enough of these meetings, you know is the kiss of death). They ask a few questions that don’t go anywhere and tell you they’ll get back to you really soon. Then a note comes through your rep, a week or a month later: it didn’t quite fit the mandate, or they have something similar in development.
Or nothing comes at all. Not even the courtesy of a pass. Just silence. It happens more than it should these days.
Unless you know them.
If you’re close to that executive, they call you after the pitch and give it to you straight, and you walk away knowing what was actually wrong with your idea.
Same mechanism, further up the building, with more money attached. The people who get told the truth are the people somebody already has a relationship with. Everyone else gets “well told.”
The one I didn’t, and the one I did
I’ve been on the wrong side of this and I think about it often.
I was in a room with a writer who couldn’t keep up with the show’s pace. They hadn’t been receptive to advice from some of the other writers, and I could see that no one had really gotten in the weeds with them, that not a single person had sat down and taught them to pitch story the way the rest of that room was thinking about it. I had a better connection with this writer than most people there did. I wasn’t sure this writer really had the potential to rise to the occasion. But if anyone could have given them advice that truly landed, it was me.
I had a lot going on at home at the time, and, quite honestly, I didn’t have the strength.
So I let time pass. I told myself I’d get to it next week.
They floundered. In the end they were let go.
I still feel guilty about that. It wasn’t my job. But as a fellow writer I felt like I’d abdicated a moral duty, and I don’t think I was wrong to feel that. I failed them.
Years later I was running a room and one of our assistants had an episode coming together that I could see was going to get thrown out when it reached the showrunner.
We were behind. Of course we were. That seems to be the permanent condition.
I went in anyway. I told them what wasn’t working, then got in there with them and we fixed the story before it ever reached the people who would have killed it. A network schedule doesn’t offer time and it doesn’t offer grace, and I didn’t want them finding that out the way people usually do.
I should be honest that this isn’t what was done for me. What was done for me happened in public, and I sat in that silence for twenty minutes before anyone told me anything. I gave this assistant the truth and the help before any of it became visible to others. I don’t know whether that’s an improvement. It’s possible that silence is exactly why the note went in as deep as it did.
And I had the strength for them because I liked them, which is the same reason those two writers on Proof had it for me, which is the problem I’ve just spent this whole piece describing.
We do the hard work for the people we care about. We take the easy way with everyone else, and they stay stuck, and we get to feel like we were being nice about it.
The assistant I helped is wildly successful now. I suspect they’d be the one to give me the tough note if I were lucky enough to work for them one day.
As for the writer who got let go… I don’t know where they are now. I never went looking. That’s the other thing the easy way buys you. You never have to find out.
The next time somebody sends you their script, you’ll know inside a page whether you’re going to do the work…
…and it won’t have much to do with the page.
Logan Slakter is a television writer, currently on NBC’s Line of Fire and previously Gossip Girl, Quantico and God Friended Me. He founded First Read and writes Breaking Story, a weekly newsletter about how the work gets made.
Breaking Story goes out every Thursday morning. For the next 72 hours, Hope For Film readers can get a year of it for $40, which is half the usual price.
AND…
I know you know how much value I try to bring you on HopeForFilm. If you been just doing the free subscriptions, you’ve been missing out. Not only do many of the best articles have a paywall somewhere in the article, even the free ones go behind a paywall after two weeks. But here is your chance to access everything, right here, right now! And for a whole lot less than usual.
50% off your first three months of subscribing to the Premium Offering of HopeForFilm. Special Black Friday sale, now until November 30th.
https://www.hopeforfilm.com/HopeForBlackFriday
